Social teams are built for speed. Most keep a running channel of trends and can turn around a branded take within hours. But so can everyone else. When every brand jumps on every trend at the same moment, the feed just turns into one long and predictable echo.
Our guest writer for this Growth Byte, Dejaih Smith , makes the case for caring a lot less about what’s trending. She breaks down how to separate a real cultural shift from temporary platform noise, and how to tell when to sit a trend out.
Check out her amazing work on Silence, Brand! for more!
Somewhere this week a brand’s social team lost its collective mind over a TikTok audio that started going viral over the weekend that will be dead by Thursday.
How is it that we’ve turned social media strategy into a relentless game of algorithmic whack-a-mole? Marketers are spending 80% of their energy monitoring trend dashboards, writing up skits for a microdrama idea that’s going to get canned by C-suite, and asking the exact same question: “How do we jump on this trend before it’s too late?”
Here’s my hot take: stop caring about what’s trending before you lose all sense of your brand identity.
If your entire strategy relies heavily on trendjacking, you don’t have a strategy. What you have is a fast-fashion content pipeline. Real brand equity isn’t built on algorithmic speed. It’s built on cultural permeability, brand identity, and long-term community behavior.
When you strip away the pressure to respond to every trending moment on the timeline, you open up space to actually understand how internet culture moves. If you want to stop chasing the algorithm and start building real resonance, here is how you should actually look at trends coming down the feed.
How to Spot a Trend Before It’s Trending
Most marketers wait for a trend to hit a formal trend report, a press release, or their For You Page ten times in a row before they recognize it. By the time an internet moment reaches that level of mainstream aggregation, the window for authentic cultural participation has already closed.
So where does real foresight live? I’ll give you a hint: It isn’t hidden inside a $50k/year social listening platform or an analytics dashboard.
My foresight is driven largely by the comments section as the early indicator.
When you drop a piece of content, look closely at the micro-signals in the first 6 to 12 hours post-distribution. The algorithm measures surface-level interaction, but the comment section reveals the emotional physics of the audience.
Are people dropping default emojis, or are they genuinely feeling it? Are they tagging their friends with hyper-specific insider context? Are they adding their own narrative layer onto the topic?
When the audience takes an idea and starts expanding on it unprompted right out of the gate, you aren’t just looking at high engagement, you’re holding an early indicator of a hit. True trendspotting is simply active listening in the places where digital culture is being negotiated in real-time.
The Lifespan Test: Trend vs. Noise
Not every spike in views deserves the title of “trend.” We get so blinded by vanity metrics that we constantly confuse an algorithmic push with actual cultural momentum. Just because 5M people saw a video doesn’t mean it changed how anyone thinks, talks, or buys.
To gauge the real impact of an internet moment, you have to watch how it alters community behavior.
Before I label something a trend, I have to see at least three iterations of it and ask myself: Is this giving people a new vocabulary to express their own identity, or are they just repeating an existing thing?
Think about how language, taste, and aesthetics travel across the internet. A genuine cultural shift provides people with a tool—a frame, a phrase, a visual shorthand—to name a specific feeling or perform an identity within their sub-community. It adds something lasting to the cultural lexicon.
On the flip side, if an idea completely dies out a week after the algorithm stops force-feeding it to timelines, it was never a trend. It was just temporary platform noise. If it doesn’t leave a footprint on community language or behavior, it isn’t worth anchoring your creative strategy around.
The Fit Check: Knowing When to Sit a Trend Out
FOMO is the single most expensive emotion in modern marketing. When a massive cultural wave hits, brands act like Cinderella’s stepsisters, desperately trying to get to the prince (your audience) first and jamming themselves into a glass slipper (trend) that doesn’t fit, just to be part of the internet ball.
Before committing creative resources to a trending audio or meme, start by asking: does it match the brand’s identity & legacy?
Every brand has an established ethos, a tone, and a reason for existing. If a trend doesn’t naturally align with your brand’s identity, it is better to sit that trend out. According to Dash Social’s 2026 Social Media Trends Report, over half of views on both Instagram (55%) and TikTok (54%) now come from non-followers, meaning your content is constantly serving as a first impression. In that discovery environment, generic trend-chasing falls flat: brand-distinctive posts generate 35% more saves and 18% more shares on TikTok (and 23% more saves on Instagram) than generic content.
Showing up late to a meme format with zero unique brand POV to bring to the feed does far more damage to your brand equity than staying quiet ever could. If you don’t have a real angle, keep it in the drafts (aka silence, brand!).
How to Know If Jumping on a Trend Actually Worked
Getting 2M+ views on a trend-jacked video might look impressive in an end-of-month reporting deck, but if it didn’t build affinity or deepen your relationship with the audience, it was just empty noise.
I know a trend strategy worked when the audience is the one making the noise.
True success isn’t measured in passive, top-of-funnel impressions. It is rooted in increased, measurable community behavior. When evaluating the impact of a trend-led piece of content, all eyes should be on shares and saves.
Saves mean the user found the content valuable enough to index into their personal digital archive.
Shares mean the user felt the content spoke for them so accurately that they used it as currency in their group chats or Stories.
When your audience starts doing the heavy lifting of distribution for you because the content felt that real to them, you won. (And as a bonus: a stack of unsolicited compliments to the social team in the comments is always appreciated.)
TL;DR: The Anti-Trendmaxxing Cheat Sheet
You don’t need to be the fastest brand on the timeline. You just need to be the clearest about who you are. Here’s a quick rundown on what you should do:
Read the comments, not the dashboards: Watch the conversations your audience is drumming up about your content in the first 6–12 hours post-distribution.
Test the lifespan: If it doesn’t move people in a new way or dies when the algorithm stops pushing it—skip it. It’s not a trend you want to engage in (if it’s even a trend at all).
Fit Check: If the trend doesn’t match your brand’s mission/legacy, keep it in the drafts.
Track the noise: Ignore passive views. Measure saves, shares, and audience participation.
Stop chasing the algorithm’s shadow. Protect your taste, trust your brand’s POV, and remember: it’s okay not to care about what’s trending.
Cover photo sourced from 🦀 Anonymous Crab 🦀 on IG
If you’re reading this and are a Substack writer, strategist or journalist yourself, feel free to shoot us a message if you’re interested in guest writing a Growth Byte.




thank you all for having me 🥰